Scroll Saw vs. Band Saw | The Key Differences

Do you partake in wood or metal working? If yes, you will agree that wood and metal working usually involves different cutting methods as well as tools that help with the various cutting needs.

You will also agree that saws, regardless of the type, are the tools applied for cutting.

However, with so many different types of saws, as well as many kinds of materials and cutting methods, you will be confused in one or two aspects as it is tough to master all of them.

In this article, we are going to compare the two common types of saws; the scroll, and the band saw which has many similar applications, and differences that make them such charming woodworking machines.

Now, let’s set our pot boiling.

Get to know some of the differences that separate band saws and scroll saws before deciding which type is right for you and your needs.

Scroll Saw Overview

Scroll saw is the tool you need to cut curves accurately. It can be powered by electricity or operated with the pedal. It is not far different to a band saw but differs only in the way it is used.

A band saw cuts a material by sliding on the surface, whereas a scroll saw is used with repeated up and down movements.

The saw is very practical and requires little space. It is very convenient in small and limited workspaces, such as in the kitchen or a backyard.

Uses of The Scroll Saw

The scroll saw is considered as a power tool. It is applied by craftsmen who deal with wood and other things in detail and is a freehand saw that lets you cut faster and look like jigsaws.

But these are easier to use and produce very accurate cuts. Scroll saw is used by people who are involved in arts and crafts.

With a scroll saw, you could create beautiful and unique patterns as well as designs for your work that can be used to make the smallest items. This saw can be used to cut wood into small parts. It is a handy tool to anyone partaking in woodwork or projects that require very good detailing or design.

Band Saw Overview

A band saw is a machine used in woodworking, which has a continuous band and is driven by two wheels. This band consists of teeth and is operated in an endless loop.

It differs from a normal saw because a standard saw uses the reciprocating motion to cut the wood, but a band saw uses the continuous loop. These machines can be either vertical or horizontal.

Uses of A Band Saw

A band saw has many applications in woodworking, for example, sawing a piece of wood and cutting board into two or more pieces. It can also be used to cut irregular shapes, curved shapes, etc.

You can also stack several pieces of wood together and cut with the help of these. The narrow saw blades of these saws make it possible to cut even small, sensitive or specific curves.

The band saw can also achieve miter or angled cuts, but the result would not be as impressive and precise as the result of a table saw. When used in woodworking, it is essential to adjust the tension and blade.

This makes the difference when cutting, as it not only makes the cut accurate but also prevents the blade from breaking.

Since this saw blade works under high tension and load, even the slightest misalignment can lead to a breakage of the saw blade.

The Key Differences

Many people conclude that two types of saws are both applied to cut nice curve, but what their real differences are for many of us is more of a puzzle than a fact.

Here, we come with a challenge that will change your thinking today after reading these differences.

Structural Differences

You can easily see the structural differences between scroll and band saw when comparing their area of application.

Size and Blades

The band saw is bigger than its brother, and although we know that they can both be applied to make curved cuts, their saw blades are very different.

A band saw blade, as its name implies, is a large ribbon or endless loop, a thin, elongated blade that turns and rotates around two wheels that spin in the same direction.

Just like a pulley system or the belt systems that are present in other power tools, the blade rotates in the endless loop. This design results in superior cut uniformity, making the band saw equally suitable for cutting wood, metal and many other manufacturing materials.

On the other hand, the scroll saw works more likely as a powered jigsaw. The saw blade is short and straight (like a jigsaw or a saw blade) and cuts with an accelerated float. The scroll saw can also work with different materials just like the band saw; it cuts only with less intensity.

Differences in Versatility

The band saw is the most and commonly preferred when it comes to cutting curves and shapes from wood. However, this fine detail work can be performed only on the outer edges of a workpiece due to the saw blade of the band saw.

However, this slight limitation does not deter many woodworkers, as the band saw is a fairly universal cutting tool.

A band saw can achieve surprisingly straight cuts, and re-grooving. This explains why you can rarely miss it in any wood workshops.

Re-grooving is a technique used to make smaller sections of wood from larger parts of wood by completely cutting or trimming a piece of wood.

This procedure is very vital as it allows you to create new pieces of useful material, and is perhaps the place where the band saw works most brilliantly.

Although the band saw is best suited for detailed curves, the scroll saw can also achieve precise curve cuts with outstanding precision. However, unlike the band saw, a scroll saw can cut complicated shapes inside a workpiece.

On the other hand, a band saw can also be applied as a perimeter cutter, by pre-drilling a small hole in a workpiece and fitting the scrub saw blade into the pre-drilled. This is especially helpful for those skilled and creative woodworkers.

Differences in Efficiency

In every respect to efficiency, the scroll saw is much more effective in detailed manual work. The machine is extremely accurate and allows for tremendous creativity in a relatively small package.

The flexibility of the scroll saw is virtually unrivaled, not only in complex curves and patterns. The tool can also achieve smooth dovetail joints, making this machine a real paradise for small, complicated crafting projects.

Similarly, the band saw takes the cake with universal efficiency and can achieve a straight line quickly and with high accuracy than a scroll saw.

Response To Some of The Commonly Asked ​​​​Questions

Many questions are surrounding the band saw and scroll, and here we respond to some of the frequently asked questions.

What are the differences between vertical and portable band saws?

Vertical band saws are freestanding, though they can be placed on a bench or stand on the ground. The blade moves vertically with the superimposed wheels.

A portable band saw is a hand-held tool that is used by an operator and is generally used for cutting stationary objects. The operator moves the saw itself, not the material to be cut. This is directly opposite of that of a vertical stationary band saw.

Which between the two is suitable to work out thick wood?

If you need to cut thicker or harder wood, a band saw is the better choice. A scroll saw can only cut the wood thickness of up 3/4 inches.

I need to cut a straight, which saw should I go for in the first place?

Wrapping up

Although many similar tasks can be achieved with both the scroll saw and band saw, there are also aspects that can make out a difference.

A band saw is a master of curved cutting, but its real vocation comes in the form of regrooving and stacking.

On the other hand, although less versatile than the band saw, the scroll saw is an ethereally skilled detailer and can achieve detailed cuts within the material. So each has its special application. Buy either one basing on your needs if the price is not a concern.

Leave a Comment